Skip to content

Serving all 50 states + Washington, DC

Keystream Plumbing logoKeystreamPlumbing

Water heaters

Water heater replacement and installation

Replacing a water heater means choosing the right type and size, then installing it to current code, which often includes a new expansion tank, venting, seismic straps or a drain pan. Most jurisdictions require a permit, which the plumber pulls.

  • Independent licensed local plumbers
  • The plumber gives you a price before work starts
  • Free referral, no obligation
Technician connecting lines on a wall-mounted heating unit

Size a tank heater by your household's peak hour, not the old tank's label alone. A 40-gallon tank suits many 2 to 3 person homes; larger families often need 50 gallons or more. Tankless heaters are sized by flow rate and your area's incoming water temperature, which is much colder in northern states than in the South.

Code has changed since many existing heaters went in. Depending on your area, the installer may need to add a thermal expansion tank, a drain pan, earthquake straps, new venting for a gas unit, or a dedicated circuit for a heat pump model. A licensed plumber knows local requirements and handles the permit and inspection.

Water Heater Replacement at a glance

Service
Water Heater Replacement
Category
Water heaters
Availability
Scheduled and same-day visits, depending on local availability
Service area
Requests accepted from all 50 states and Washington, DC; availability depends on the pros near your ZIP code
Also called
hot water heater installation, tankless water heater, new water heater
Permit
Usually required; handled by the plumber
Cost
Quoted on site by the pro before work starts; see cost factors below

Specific water heater replacement jobs

Narrower jobs within this service, each with its own guide.

Signs you need water heater replacement

  • The tank is leaking from the body
  • The heater is over 10 years old and needs a major repair
  • You regularly run out of hot water
  • Rusty hot water or heavy sediment despite flushing
  • Rising energy bills from an inefficient old unit

What the pro does, step by step

  1. 1

    Size and select

    The plumber reviews household size, fixtures, fuel type and space to recommend tank, tankless or heat pump options.

  2. 2

    Permit and prep

    Where required, a permit is pulled. Water and fuel are shut off and the old unit drained.

  3. 3

    Install to code

    The new heater is set, connected and vented, with any required expansion tank, pan, straps or valves.

  4. 4

    Start up and haul away

    The unit is filled, fired or powered, tested for leaks, set to a safe temperature, and the old heater removed.

What affects the cost of water heater replacement

Prices vary by market and job. The pro gives you a price before starting; these factors drive it.

  • Tank, tankless or heat pump
  • Capacity or flow rate
  • Gas line, venting or electrical upgrades
  • Code items like expansion tanks, pans and straps
  • Location (attic and closet installs cost more)

What you can safely do, and when to stop

Safe to do yourself

  • Find your model and serial number (the age is often encoded in the serial)
  • Clear space around the heater for access
  • Check the fuel type and vent style
  • Compare utility rebates for high-efficiency models

Stop and call a pro

  • Any gas line or venting work
  • Adding circuits for electric or heat pump units
  • Installs that need a permit where you live
  • Moving the heater to a new location

Water Heater Replacement FAQ

Should I switch to a tankless water heater?

Tankless heaters save space and never run out, but cost more to install and may need a larger gas line or venting. They make the most sense when you plan to stay in the home and your gas service can support them.

What size water heater do I need?

As a rough guide, 40 gallons for 1 to 3 people and 50 gallons or more for 3 to 5 people, adjusted for large tubs and simultaneous showers. The plumber sizes it for your household.

Do I need a permit to replace a water heater?

In most US jurisdictions, yes. Water heaters involve gas, venting or high-voltage power and a pressure relief valve, so they are inspected for safety. The plumber usually pulls the permit.

How long does installation take?

A like-for-like tank swap usually takes a few hours. Switching to tankless or relocating the heater can take most of a day.

What are the signs a water heater needs replacing rather than repair?

Water seeping from the tank body, rust-colored hot water, rumbling that continues after a flush and a tank well past ten years old all point to replacement. A failed part on a younger, dry tank is usually worth repairing.

Can I change from an electric water heater to gas, or gas to electric?

Yes, but it is more than a swap. Going to gas needs a gas line of the right size, a vent and combustion air. Going to electric needs a dedicated circuit, and a heat pump model also needs space and a condensate drain. Ask for both options to be priced.

What is a heat pump water heater?

It is an electric tank that moves heat from the surrounding air into the water instead of making heat with elements, so it uses much less electricity. It needs a room with enough air volume, a drain for condensate and more height than a standard tank.

What code upgrades can come up when a water heater is replaced?

Common ones are an expansion tank on closed systems, seismic straps where required, a drain pan with a drain line, a properly piped relief valve discharge and updated venting or gas shutoff. The inspector checks these under the permit.

What should I ask before agreeing to a water heater replacement?

Ask which brand, size and warranty are quoted, whether the permit and inspection are included, what happens to the old tank, and which code upgrades are in the price. Two quotes for the same job can differ mainly on those points.

Water Heater Replacement by location

Local water, housing and permit rules change what this job involves. Find local conditions for your area:

Water Heater Replacement city guides

Local plumbing conditions

Somewhere else? Browse plumbing conditions in all 50 states.

Get water heater replacement help now

Call (833) 520-4758 to reach an available local pro.

Call now(833) 520-4758